Dr. Simon Whitcher, a surgical registrar at John Hunter Hospital, working with academics from the University of Newcastle, analyzed data from the Newcastle Direct Access Colonoscopy Service (DACS) for the period 2014–2018 to investigate whether colonoscopy services should provide endoscopies to patients with positive FIT results with the same priority, regardless of whether the test was instigated by the NBCSP.

There were 2,365 complete screening colonoscopy outcomes analyzed: 1,233 following community-initiated and 1,132 following NBCSP testing.

"Colonoscopy quality was high: the completion rate … was 97.1% (community-initiated, 1,193 of 1,233, 96.8%; NBCSP, 1,104 of 1,132, 97.5%), and the adenoma detection rate was 49%, exceeding international benchmarks for either symptomatic or screening patients," the researchers found.

"The rate of colorectal neoplasia (malignant or pre-malignant) was similar in the two groups. Importantly, the difference in the rates of adenocarcinoma was not statistically significant (community-initiated, 4.0%; NBCSP, 2.7%)."

Whitcher and colleagues concluded that "evaluation should be performed equally promptly for patients with positive results from NBSCP and community-initiated FITs."

"The incidence and detection rates of colorectal neoplasia in people aged 50–74 years were similar for people with positive results for FITs undertaken as part of the NBCSP or community-initiated."